Princess Peach may have slept through the night last night, but I stayed up late working and am seriously beat this morning despite two or three cups of coffee (too tired to remember which). I'm also continuing to work, because, well, I need the money to feed Princess Peach and buy more coffee.
I'm working on a project that involves sex offender registration. I'm squeamish about violence in general, but sex crimes are particularly outrageous because they completely strip a victim of his or her sense of control and leave them helpless and fearful. These are inexcusable crimes. What to do with the perpetrators?
As a dyed-in-the-wool liberal, I think incarceration is a pointless exercise: all it does is remove the person from society for a brief period of time. Practically, it's a huge waste of human potential, however vilely those humans have behaved. Plus, I look at it as their grad school or a criminal think tank. Therapy rarely helps and recidivism rates are high. And don't get me started on the trend toward civil commitment -- it gives me the creeps and makes me think of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn novels.
I'm ambivalent about sex offender registration, because I think it is overinclusive in some ways (the 18 year old and the 15 year old girlfriend, that sort of thing) and underinclusive in others (rapists who plead to lesser charges for reduced sentences). But if that guy was living next door to me -- yeah, I would want to know.
I recently picked up a book about Australia's early days, and was reminded of Heinlein's The Moon is a Harsh Mistress, where the moon, like Australia, was initially populated by criminal and political prisoners. It made me wonder...just what is so wrong with the idea of a prison colony? Not just for sex offenders, but for anyone convicted for a particular set of violent crimes. (And greedy corporate tools who bilk investors to line their own pockets -- Enron, anyone?) Maybe England had the right idea.
If the goal is to keep society safe, then a prison colony is a safety valve -- no worrying about return. If the goal is rehabilitation, a mirrored society could provide a way for criminals to become invested in the system -- in running the colony, operating businesses, developing products. Instead of farming production of goods out to sweatshops in China, we could farm production out to prison colonies. Ultimately, there would be a way to demonstrate readiness to rejoin society at large.
Ah, well. My 30 minutes of musing time is up -- back to work...
Recent Comments